jason hirschhorn's @MusicREDEF: 01/24/2023 - Ticketmaster Goes to Washington, Can YouTube Win Music?, Drake, Superfans, Brad Mehldau...

When you have monopolies, you get problems.
Open in browser
Tuesday January 24, 2023
REDEF
If you're reading this in bed, it's too late: Drake at the Apollo Theater, New York, Jan. 21, 2023.
(Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty Images)
quote of the day
"When you have monopolies, you get problems."
- Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., who'll co-lead a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing this morning on competition in the ticketing industry
rantnrave://
Ticket to Chide

Democrats and Republicans in Washington don't seem to agree on anything these days, but apparently they can get together on this: "TICKETMASTER Sucks," as a New Republic report from Capitol Hill indelicately put it Monday. The magazine asked 15 senators about Ticketmaster, PABLO MANRÍQUEZ reported, and "None had anything good to say about it or LIVE NATION ENTERTAINMENT." So that's what Live Nation president/CFO JOE BERCHTOLD will be facing when he testifies before the SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE this morning on competition—or the lack thereof—in the ticketing industry: unified, bipartisan rage at his company's disastrous handling of tickets for TAYLOR SWIFT's ERAS tour last fall, buoyed by years of frustration at Ticketmaster/Live Nation's dominant position in the live music business.

The music biz, though, isn't quite so unified, and neither are some of the smartest industry observers and analysts. Ticketing is layered and complicated, not unlike the fees everyone hates.

Ticketmaster, not surprisingly, blames scalpers and their bots for its own Taylor Swift ticketing screwup, and that's where Berchtold will point his finger this morning. He'll ask the legislators to take action against secondary ticket sellers who get inventory from bot operations and, Billboard reports, against speculative ticket sales—the insidious practice of offering tickets for resale that the reseller doesn't actually have yet. Others testifying today, including SEAT GEEK exec JACK GROETZINGER and Chicago promoter JERRY MICKELSON, are likely to point fingers right back at Ticketmaster and parent Live Nation for their stranglehold on the market, including long-term exclusive arrangements with Live Nation venues (where concerts are often promoted, too, by Live Nation subsidiaries). The idea of breaking up exclusive ticketing deals for venues and even for individual shows has plenty of support around the industry.

The senators may also hear artists blamed for the sky-high prices of some tickets—which artists and their teams, and not ticketing companies, are responsible for setting. And maybe someone will suggest, as ex-Ticketmaster CEO FRED ROSEN did in the LA Times, that fans themselves are to blame for ticket prices, because years of downloading music for free "helped create this situation where artists have to make all their money on tour." (It's unclear if he thinks streaming music companies should share in that blame, too.)

The LA Times' AUGUST BROWN has a good, sober overview on what Ticketmaster is and isn't doing—and can and can't do—to move the needle on ticket prices, fees and availability. The NY Times' JON CARAMANICA and BEN SISARIO discuss some of the most recent debacles (it wasn't just Taylor Swift) and the deeper issues behind them on the Times' POPCAST. And BILL WERDE, of Syracuse's BANDIER PROGRAM, offered a holistic view of the problem in November in his FULL RATE NO CAP newsletter. (In an update this week, Werde was skeptical of concrete action coming out of today's hearing, but suggests there are some areas where Congress might get involved, including in resale pricing and service fee transparency.)

Can the senators and the various wings of the industry see beyond the immediate Taylor Swift (or BAD BUNNY or BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN) crisis and zoom out to the structural issues that have led us here? Democratic SEN. AMY KLOBUCHAR of Minnesota, who'll run today's hearing with Republican SEN. MIKE LEE of Utah, tells Rolling Stone the one thing the committee can't do today is "nothing at all" because "that hasn't worked out very well for consumers."

The hearing will be livestreamed here at 10 am ET. (I have some final questions for whoever made the decision to schedule it for the same morning as the ACADEMY AWARD nominations, but I'll table those for now, so as not to distract from the issue at hand. Which hopefully the movie news itself won't do.)

Dot Dot Dot

"It's like management du jour, everyone is going and laying off 5 to 10% of their workers"—and now it's reached the music space, with SPOTIFY planning to lay off 6% of its staff, about 600 people. The company also announced Monday that chief content officer DAWN OSTROFF, who has overseen Spotify's aggressive expansion into podcasting—a spending spree that hasn't always sat well with the music community—is stepping down. "In hindsight," CEO DANIEL EK wrote in a blog post, "I was too ambitious in investing ahead of our revenue growth." Spotify reported in October that usership and revenues were growing but so were losses. It said subscription price hikes are likely in 2023... Dear New York City: If your police department is actually interested in engaging with the city's hip-hop community, maybe it isn't the best idea to station a police officer with a video camera outside a DRAKE concert in Harlem, recording every fan as they walk out. And by "maybe," I mean it's an objectively horrible idea, no matter how the police and MAYOR ERIC ADAMS spin it. If you're not convinced how awful it is, try to imagine crowds of concertgoers walking out of a NEW YORK PHILHARMONIC or BILLY JOEL show directly into a phalanx of cops, one of whom has a video camera trained on them. You can't, can you?... BLACK PANTHER: WAKANDA FOREVER and ELVIS lead the pack of nominees for the GUILD OF MUSIC SUPERVISORS AWARDS, to be handed out March 5 in Los Angeles. They were music-supervised, respectively, by DAVE JORDAN and ANTON MONSTED... How to be happy, according to a jazz saxophone master.

Rest In Peace

LIN BREHMER, a longtime morning DJ at Chicago rock radio station WXRT whose warm voice and deep love and knowledge of the music he played endeared him to the city. Former Mayor Rahm Emanuel called him "the voice of Chicago." "He didn't have a signature bit, no clever catch phrase," Steve Albini tweeted. "What Lin conveyed was that he was a guy listening to music, sharing it with you, and any gimmick or artifice would only spoil the atmosphere of familiarity, relegating it to hokum"... Songwriter GINNY REDINGTON DAWES, whose songs were recorded by Sarah Vaughan and Eddy Arnold but who was best known for her jingles for Coke ("Coke Is It"), McDonald's, Kit Kat bars and other iconic brands... MARSHALL TUCKER, a South Carolina piano tuner whose name was appropriated by a Southern rock band he'd never met. Marshall Tucker was finally introduced to the Marshall Tucker Band—who borrowed his name after seeing it on a key to the warehouse they were renting as a rehearsal space—when a friend saw an ad for one of their shows and thought they were him. "Though he was never a member of our band, we wouldn't be here today without his historic name," the band wrote... TJ DE BLOIS, original drummer for Philadelphia metal band A Life Once Lost.

- Matty Karas, curator
call ticketron
Los Angeles Times
Everyone hates Ticketmaster. Is everyone wrong?
By August Brown
Fans, politicians and even artists were complaining about Ticketmaster long before Taylor Swift filled stadiums. But experts say the anger may be misplaced.
Rolling Stone
Amy Klobuchar's Scrutinized Live Nation and Ticketmaster for Years. Will a Major Senate Hearing Increase Breakup Calls?
By Ethan Millman
"How can we change the conditions and the rules of the game so we actually can spawn competition?," Minnesota senator says ahead of a hearing she's leading Tuesday. "I want to hear that from them."
Trapital
YouTube Wants to Be #1 in Music. Will it Happen?
By Dan Runcie
It's tough to dominate both audio and video.
The Verge
Taylor Swift and the music industry's next $20
By Nilay Patel and Charlie Harding
Streaming's the problem. It's streaming.
Music Ally
What do we mean by 'artist-centric' music streaming models?
By Stuart Dredge
This month, UMG boss Sir Lucian Grainge went public with his belief that "the economic model for streaming needs to evolve." But his choice of words was a signal that UMG isn't about to throw its weight behind calls for user-centric payouts.
The New York Times
Drake: Rap's Biggest Fan
By Jon Caramanica
Hip-hop can sometimes discourage rappers from openly embracing their heroes, but Drake wears his enthusiasms loudly and, this past week, literally.
Gothamist
'Let them keep complaining': Adams dismisses critics of NYPD taking videos of Drake concertgoers in Harlem
By Elizabeth Kim
An NYPD spokesperson says the video of concertgoers should only be used to promote community events, but some are expressing concerns of racist surveillance.
Decential
Where Do 'Superfans' Fit into Web3 Music? The Latest Water and Music Wavelengths Session Asks
By MacEagon Voyce
Why it's still difficult to discover and cultivate deeper connections between musicians and their fans.
The New Yorker
Brad Mehldau Trades Bach for the Beatles
By Andrew Marantz
The jazz pianist wanders among his old West Village haunts and bumps into a band buddy who owes him cash.
WNYC
Saxophonist David Murray returns to the New York jazz scene in a new role
By Piotr Orlov
After two decades abroad, a onetime pillar of New York's music and theater communities has come home to as an elder statesman for a new generation of jazz musicians.
two tickets to paradise
Los Angeles Times
Spotify reduces staff by 6%, Chief Content Officer Dawn Ostroff to leave
By Wendy Lee
Spotify says it is cutting staff as it focuses on improving efficiency in a challenging economic environment.
Culture Notes of an Honest Broker
The Bizarre 2,000-Year History of Impersonating Famous Musicians
By Ted Gioia
But nowadays it's done by corporations.
Billboard
How Will 2022's Music Consumption Trends Impact Catalog Valuations?
By Glenn Peoples
More digital consumption - from a multitude of sources - and improving margins are positive news for catalog valuations.
Variety
David Crosby Was Working on a Planned Tour and New Album Up to the Day He Died, Collaborators Say
By Chris Willman
Crosby was active literally to the end — and 'giddy' about going over setlists and concert logistics hours before he died, musician Steve Postell reveals. Sarah Jarosz talks about recording her part for a new album days before his death.
Lefsetz Letter
David Crosby
By Bob Lefsetz
David Crosby was a difficult man. But he was brilliant.
Resident Advisor
The Rising Cost of Everything: Inflation Hits UK Clubland
By Anu Shukla
With artist fees skyrocketing and energy bills hiking upwards of 300 percent, people in the music industry are grappling with an increasingly expensive - and volatile - future.
DJ Mag
Exploring the cosmic connection between Chicago jazz label International Anthem and London's Total Refreshment Centre
By Sam Walton
A recent showcase at the Barbican Centre celebrated the works of Chicago label International Anthem and London venue Total Refreshment Centre.
The Guardian
'Ritual humiliations': African music stars struggle to get visas to Europe
By Caroline Kimeu
A Kenyan DJ's post of being denied transit through Amsterdam has put the spotlight on airlines' alleged racist policies.
The Spectator
In defence of Spotify
By Josiah Gogarty
Streaming is keeping recorded music alive.
Toronto Star
RETRO READ: We went undercover as ticket scalpers — and Ticketmaster offered to help us do business
By Robert Cribb and Marco Chown Oved
Posing as small-time scalpers, Star and CBC reporters talked to representatives of Ticketmaster's resale division who said the company wants to share in ticket resale profits by facilitating mass scalping - in direct violation of its own terms of use.
what we're into
Music of the day
"Ticket Inspector"
The Chats
Australian punk rock, from "Get F***ed" (2022).
Video of the day
"Ticketmaster Recruits Pros for Secret Scalper Program"
CBC News
This 2018 CBC investigation is a companion video to the Toronto Star piece linked above.
Music | Media
SUBSCRIBE
Suggest a link
"REDEF is dedicated to my mother, who nurtured and encouraged my interest in everything and slightly regrets the day she taught me to always ask 'why?'"
Jason Hirschhorn
CEO & Chief Curator
HOME | ABOUT | SETS | PRESS
Redef Group Inc.
LA - NY - Everywhere
Copyright ©2021
UNSUBSCRIBE or MANAGE MY SUBSCRIPTION

No comments:

Re-Slim Dunlap

Slimbob Dunlap was one in a million. The outpouring of love for him here in Minneapolis since the news broke is overwhelming. Everyone has a...